Organic foods are produced without synthetic pesticides, fertilizers, antibiotics, or hormones — qualities many associate with safety. But a recent Salmonella outbreak tied to organic eggs across seven states has prompted readers to ask: Are organic foods always safer?

Organic products are often marketed as cleaner, greener, and healthier — but food safety is more complex. And the real question is: safer from what?

This week’s Wednesday Weigh-In asked: “Do you think organic foods are always safer than non-organic foods?” Your responses — paired with scientific insights and government data — paint a picture of what “safe” really means.

Let’s dive in and explore some answers.

🗳️ Poll Results:

Do you think organic foods are always safer than non-organic foods?

Here’s how you voted:

🦠 No, organic can still carry risks – 80%

🔍 It depends on handling and processing – 13%

🌿 Yes, organic is always safer – 5%

❓ I’m not sure, need more info – 2%

The majority (80%) of you rejected the idea that organic foods are always safer, noting that pathogens like Salmonella don’t discriminate between organic and conventional products. The 13% who chose “It depends” emphasized that proper handling and processing are just as — if not more — important than how a food is grown or raised.

💬 What You Said

Your comments reflect a nuanced understanding of organic food safety:

• Skepticism about organic safety: “Organic or conventional has absolutely no bearing on food safety!”

• Pathogen risks in organic farming: “Organic farms are just as susceptible to pathogens as conventional farms. Birds and wildlife can pose disease problems.”

• Manure concerns: “Organic ALWAYS carries a greater risk of fecal bacteria contamination. Organic intentionally uses animal feces, i.e., manure, as a primary source of nitrogen.”

• Handling and processing matter: “I’d love to believe organic is safer, but no food is safe if it’s handled or processed poorly.”

• Pesticide benefits: “The significantly reduced pesticide and chemical contamination is a huge upside to organic food, especially for young children.”

• Distrust in the organic label: “Organic is nothing but a marketing tool in my opinion.”

• Regulatory concerns: “The organic program is very flawed in itself anyway — the farms self-certify, which is ridiculous.”

• No food safety requirements: “Organic regulations don’t have any regulatory food safety aspects.”

Many readers raised concerns about organic farming practices, especially the use of manure, which can introduce pathogens if not properly composted. Others noted that organic certification doesn’t directly address food safety protocols — just production methods.

🔬 What the Science Says

Pathogen Risks

Organic and conventional foods face similar risks of contamination from pathogens like Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria. Notable findings include:

• A 2018 study in Frontiers in Microbiology found no significant difference in pathogen contamination between organic and conventional produce.

• A 2006 Journal of Food Science study and a 2009 Kansas State University study both found no significant difference in E. coli prevalence between organic and conventional produce and cattle.

• Organic farming’s reliance on manure can elevate pathogen risks if composting is inadequate. As one reader from Ireland noted, “Organic and free-range birds roam outside during the day — they’re exposed to Salmonella from mixing with or being exposed to vermin feces.”

Pesticide and Chemical Residues

Organic foods tend to have lower levels of synthetic pesticide residues:

• A 2012 Harvard Health study found that organic produce has fewer synthetic pesticide residues, although both organic and conventional foods are typically within EPA safety limits.

• Organic animal products are free of antibiotics and growth hormones.

• However, natural pesticides used in organic farming are not automatically safer. A 2015 Harvard article noted the safety of organic pesticides remains unclear and should not be assumed.

Nutritional Comparison

Though not directly related to safety, many readers asked about nutrition:

• A 2019 systematic review found little difference in macronutrients (protein, fat, carbs) between organic and conventional foods.

• Organic consumers often have healthier diets overall, but researchers attribute this more to lifestyle factors than the food itself.

🏛️ Government Oversight and Standards

Organic foods are regulated by both the USDA and FDA:

• USDA Organic Standards: The USDA’s National Organic Program (NOP) regulates organic labeling, requiring a 3-year field transition and strict composting rules for manure. However, it doesn’t enforce food safety protocols beyond what conventional farms must follow.

• FDA’s Role: The FDA oversees food safety for both organic and non-organic products and emphasizes proper handling and processing across the board.

• Recent Updates: In 2023, the USDA strengthened organic rules to increase inspections and transparency in certification.

Despite these efforts, organic certification focuses on how food is produced, not necessarily whether it’s safe to eat.

🧼 The Role of Handling and Processing

Many of you (13%) emphasized that safety depends on how food is handled, not just whether it’s labeled organic. Science agrees:

• Poor sanitation during processing can contaminate any food. The FDA’s Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) mandates preventive controls for all types of food, regardless of label.

• Organic standards restrict some chemical sanitizers, which may increase risks in certain situations.

• Washing produce can reduce but not eliminate contamination. Good agricultural and handling practices remain essential.

🥚 Current Event: Organic Egg Recall

A nationwide recall has been issued for organic and cage-free eggs from August Egg Company following a Salmonella outbreak that sickened at least 79 people across nine states. 

The CDC and FDA have linked the illnesses to eggs sold under multiple brands at major retailers, including Safeway, Ralphs, and Food 4 Less.

The recall underscores that while organic labeling may imply health benefits, it doesn’t guarantee freedom from harmful pathogens like Salmonella.

📊 Comparing Organic and Conventional Safety

• Pathogen Risk: Both organic and conventional foods have similar risks of contamination from pathogens like Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria; risks may increase in organic if manure is mismanaged, and safety depends on proper handling for both.

• Pesticide Residues: Organic foods have lower synthetic pesticide residues and use natural alternatives, while conventional foods may have higher synthetic residues, typically within EPA safety limits.

• Antibiotics/Hormones: Organic animal products do not use antibiotics or growth hormones, while conventional livestock production may include their use.

• Regulatory Oversight: Organic foods are regulated by the USDA’s NOP for production standards, plus FDA and USDA’s FSIS for food safety; conventional foods are regulated only by FDA/FSIS food safety standards.

• Processing Risks: Organic processing restricts certain chemical sanitizers, which may increase contamination risks in some cases, while conventional processing allows sanitizer use that can reduce risks.

✅ What You Can Do

No matter what kind of food you eat, here are a few steps to stay safe:

• Wash produce thoroughly: Rinse under running water to reduce dirt and bacteria.

• Cook high-risk foods: Eggs, poultry, and meat should be cooked to safe internal temperatures.

• Stay informed: Follow recall alerts from the FDA, USDA, and Food Safety News.

• Choose trusted sources: Look for the USDA Organic seal or other third-party certifications, and ask questions about handling practices if you can.

Final Thoughts

Your responses reveal strong skepticism about organic food safety, with 80% rejecting the idea that it’s “always safer.” While organic foods reduce exposure to synthetic pesticides and additives, they don’t inherently reduce the risk of bacterial contamination.

As one reader put it: “Bacteria cannot tell the difference.”

The bottom line? Food safety isn’t just about how something is grown — it’s about how it’s handled from farm to fork.

What’s Your Take?

Do you trust the organic label, or do you take extra precautions?

(Keep it respectful; personal attacks or ads will be removed.)

Thanks for reading, and we’ll see you on Monday with more Food Safety News.

And Happy Father’s Day to all the dads, grandpas, and father figures out there — whether you're grilling safely, packing lunches, or just making sure the milk isn't expired, we salute you. Enjoy the day (and maybe a second helping of dessert)!

Jonan Pilet,

Newsletter Editor

Weekend Poll

Past Week’s Recalls

U.S. Recalls

• USDA orders recall of catfish products from Vietnam because of export status

• Comvita Manuka Honey products recalled because of leaking packaging

• Rocky Road Ice Cream recalled because of undeclared allergens and mislabeled packaging

• Nearly 50 tons of dry milk recalled because of potential Salmonella contamination

• Enoki mushrooms recalled nationwide because of Listeria contamination

• Cooked & Peeled Coldwater Shrimp Meat recalled because of Listeria concerns

• Salted Smoked Split Herring because of possible of Clostridium Botulinum concerns

• Washington company recalls salmon after tests show Listeria contamination

• Giant Instant Oatmeal recalled for undeclared walnuts

• Chocolate pudding recalled because of damage to containers

• Nationwide egg recall issued as Salmonella outbreak sickens 79 across 7 states

Canadian Recalls

• Genoa Salami recalled in Canada because of Salmonella contamination

• More recalls…

Don’t forget…

Do you know someone who would like this newsletter? Share it with them.

Interested in reaching food safety-conscious readers like you? To become a Food Safety News partner, apply here.